Cup Custards
Mrs. LincolnScald one quart of rich, creamy milk. Beat four egg yolks, and add to them four tablespoons sugar and half a teaspoon of salt; beat until thick like cream. Separately, beat the four egg whites until foamy, but not stiff. Add to the yolks, and add hot milk. Stand pudding cups in a shallow pan in the oven. Stir the foam down and fill the cups to nearly overflowing. Put hot water in the pan and bake in a hot oven, watching carefully so they do not scorch. Lay buttered parchment paper on top if needed. Test with a knife as soon as they begin to puff; they are done when the knife comes out clean and not milky. A little nutmeg may be used on top if wished.
Rice Pudding
Mrs. LincolnKnown also as poor man's pudding. Soak three tablespoons of washed rice and three tablespoons of milk in a quart of milk for half an hour. Then bake very slowly, stirring to the bottom two or three times, for two or three hours, until rice is soft, whole, and surrounded by a rich syrup. It should not bake dry or be crunchy. Serve hot with butter or cold with cream. Optionally, add raisins, apples, or prunes, cooked with the rice.
Sago Pudding
Mrs. Lincoln(editor's note: tapioca!)
Scald one quart of milk in a double boiler. Add one third of a cup of sago and half a level teaspoon of salt and cook for one hour or until transparent, stirring frequently. Add one tablespoon of butter, and one beaten egg. Melt half a cup of sugar in a saucepan until brown; deglaze with half a cup of water, and stir into the sago. This creates a caramel flavor. Turn into a greased pudding dish and bake about twenty minutes. Eat hot with butter.
Spice Pudding
Mrs. LincolnMix two cups of sifted pastry flour, one teaspoon of baking soda, one teaspoon of baking powder, two large tablespoons of mixed spice, half a teaspoon of salt, half a cup of chopped raisins, and a quarter cup of chopped nuts. Moisten with a half cup of sour cream, a half cup of molasses, and two tablespoons of butter. Grease half-pint tin cups or half pound cans, fill halfway with batter, cover with buttered parchment paper or tin covers, and set them on a pan in a kettle of boiling water and cook about one hour. Replenish the water as needed, keeping half of the containers in the water at all time. Serve with lemon sauce.
Ginger Pudding
Mrs. ArmstrongMix together one and a half cups of flour, one teaspoon of ginger, one teaspoon of baking soda, one cup molasses, two thirds of a cup of boiling water, and one beaten egg. Steam for an hour in a tube pan, and serve with any pudding sauce.
Batter Pudding
Mrs. ArmstrongSift together one and a half cups of flour, one and a half teaspoons of baking powder, and one quarter teaspoon of salt. Beat four eggs well, add one pint of milk, and mix well with sifted flour mixture. Add stiffly beaten egg whites, and bake in a hot oven. Serve promptly when done.
Strawberry Sauce (for batter pudding)
Mrs. ArmstrongCream four tablespoons of butter, and add one cup of powdered sugar and one egg yolk. Beat in half a cup of fresh berries, preserved fruit, or jam. Chill well before serving.